All Leather, No Wood: the Mark Belanger Story – Romantic About Baseball
A Blog for The Thinking Fan
All Leather, No Wood: the Mark Belanger Story
March 21, 2020 category 2 Comments;

“There’d be two men on base and one out, and somebody would hit a ball into the hole. We knew the ball wasn’t going through. Either Brooks or Mark would get it. Double play.”

Earl Weaver

Imagine stepping on to the ball field, sun beaming down, the crowd crescendoing from an anxious buzz to a rolling roar. The dirt crackling under your spikes turns to the pleasant pff of grass as you cross into fair territory. You know what the fans came to see, and it’s just over to your right. It’s the guy with the glove: “Mr. Impossible,” they call him. He’s a Hall of Famer, and you know it. They say he’s peerless, king of the mountain. You just call him Brooks, and you also know something that will be washed away with time:

You’re not just his peer with the glove; you may be even better.

Of course the guy to your left in this vision is Brooks “The Human Vacuum Cleaner” Robinson: Hall of Famer, owner of 16 Gold Glove awards, and participant in 18 All-Star Games. Whenever people are assembling their ‘all defense’ teams, he is almost always the unanimous choice among both the casual fan who saw him play and the analytical-minded nerd (meant affectionately) who appreciates his epic prowess at the hot corner.

Who are you in this little exercise? You are Mark “The Blade” Belanger. You took the field about 45 feet to the left of Brooks Robinson from 1965 until 1977, and you completed what is easily the most dominant left side of the infield in the history of baseball. You are the proud owner of eight Gold Gloves and two World Series rings yourself, and you’ve accumulated the most (at the time) defensive Wins Above Replacement EVER. You were also part of one of the greatest defensive units of the era, thanks to the aforementioned Brooks Robinson and Paul Blair, and eventually Davey Johnson and Bobby Grich.

For some context on this defensive supergroup, check out my friend Bailey, from Foolish Baseball, talking about them in this video:

SIDE NOTE: If you have a Youtube account and DON’T subscribe to Foolish Baseball, then you can make like Mark Belanger at the plate and you can GET OUT! (More on that later)

The fact is that working such a critical position, on a team so elite for such a sustained period of time, means that you must have been one badass dude with the leather. If the shortstop is the glue of the infield, then Belanger was of the premium Krazy variety. One of his signature moves was his double-play-turning ability, and the accuracy with which he set up his second baseman. The evidence for this prowess came in the form of his second baseman, whether it was Davey Johnson (in 1969 and 1971) or the legendary Bobby Grich (1973–1976), who also took home Gold Gloves. Those would be the only seasons either player would win the award (Except in 1970 when Johnson won while playing next to Belanger. Luis Aparicio won the GG for short stop that season). He just made guys around him better, which is exactly what the field general is supposed to do.

So here’s the problem . . . he simply could not hit. Like AT ALL.

If Belanger was Miles Davis in the field, he was Kenny G at the plate. He simply could not string anything productive together, assembling an abysmal .228/.300/.280 triple slash line and managing only one season of peaking his OPS+ to the 100 plateau (literally league average). In 1970, his bat was nearly muted entirely, hitting .218, putting up just a single home run, and driving in 36 runs (good for a .562 OPS, or a 56 OPS+) over 527 plate appearances. This would earn him the dubious title of the ninth ever ‘triple crown loser.’ In 1976, he managed to string together that league average season mentioned above, slashing .270/.336/.326 and earning his first (and only) All Star selection in the process. This would be the only really respectable season that “The Blade” (a name he acquired in regards to his tall, slender frame) could put together at the dish, despite playing at least 100 games from 1968 through 1980.

Brooks Robinson, Mark Belanger, Davey Johnson, and Boog Powell

It’s been thought that his time with the Orioles came to an end when he began questioning the leadership tactics of the team’s legendary manager, Earl Weaver. He accused the skipper of “losing his managerial prowess,” and further insinuated that it had been going on for some time. It wasn’t long after these accusations that he wasn’t extended a contract. He played one season with the Los Angeles Dodgers before retiring.

Belanger died in 1998 at the age of 54, from complications related to lung cancer. His legacy on the field was for his smooth glove and precise arm, and off the field it was for being an advocate for players’ rights. He said that playing as key a role as he did, in the 1981 players strike alongside Marvin Miller, was a “free, but expensive” education. He continued to work with players and the union even after he hung up his spikes, spending 16 years working with the MLBPA to help lay critical groundwork for many of the substantial contracts that players see today. In the history of labor negotiations in modern baseball history, Mark Belanger deserves a bullet point in that outline.

“Belanger would glide effortlessly after a grounder and welcome it into loving arms; scooping the ball up with a single easy motion, and bringing it to his chest for a moment’s caress before making his throw.”

Pat Jordan, Sports Illustrated (via SABR)

2 Comments

Wayne Laufert says:

It’s nice to remember what the Blade contributed to some of the great Orioles teams, so thank you for that, Adam. However, you made a few errors. Belanger hit .270, not .276, in 1976. More importantly, ’76 was not “the only really respectable season [he] could put together at the dish.” In 1969, he compiled a .287/.351/.345 slash with 2 homers and a career-high 50 RBI, finishing 29th in the MVP voting. (Two other times, for what it’s worth, he finished higher in MVP voting, although in both those years–neither of which was 1976–he was close to his career slash line. That speaks volumes about his fielding.) True, his OPS+ in ’69 was only 95, lower than in ’76, but if the latter season was respectable, so was the former. One could also make a case for 1971, when Belanger had a 97 OPS+, his second best, albeit with zero home runs. … Oh, and Brooks Robinson of course played to the RIGHT of Belanger, contrary to what you state in the first two longer paragraphs. Just after that, you do have Belanger playing to the left of Brooks, which is accurate. But I can’t figure out what you mean by “You’re not just his peer with the glove, but you may be just as good.” Both “peer” and “just as good” mean equal. … Anyway, best wishes with your website.

Hey Wayne! Thanks for the read and the critique! I corrected that mis-type on his batting average, finger just slipped there! I did correct my wording on the passage in regards to his juxtaposition to Brooks. I do understand your point on his respectable offensive seasons, but the jist of the article was really to illustrate how great the discrepancy was between his glove and bat, and using OPS+ by it’s purest definition, in every season except ’76, he graded out as below average, and here i’ve chosen to use the word “respectable” to insinuate “average”. I think it’s fair to say he’s not getting any MVP votes because of his bat. I can’t thank you enough for your critical eye, and I sincerely appreciate you checking things out here! – Adam

Leave a Reply to Wayne Laufert Cancel reply

Podcast Feed
%d bloggers like this: